| | | Bluffton wins coin toss and defers to second half |
| Ec | 1-10 | at Ec35 | BU ball on BU35. |
| | | A. Sweeney kickoff 65 yards to the EC0, touchback. |
| Ec | 1-10 | at Ec20 | Matt Couch rush for 8 yards to the EC28 (B. Schamp). |
| Ec | 2-2 | at Ec28 | PENALTY EC false start 5 yards to the EC23. |
| Ec | 2-7 | at Ec23 | Matt Couch pass complete to Lance Sherwood for 1 yard to the EC24. |
| Ec | 3-6 | at Ec24 | Matt Couch pass incomplete to Kenny Williams (P. Shroyer). |
| Ec | 4-6 | at Ec24 | Kaleb Lingg punt 15 yards to the EC39, out-of-bounds. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 4 yards, TOP 01:25 |
| Bu | 1-10 | at Ec39 | BLUFFTON drive start at 13:35. |
| Bu | 1-10 | at Ec39 | N. Sheehan pass complete to S. Frost for 5 yards to the EC34, out-of-bounds. |
| Bu | 2-5 | at Ec34 | N. Sheehan pass complete to C.J. Sewell for 8 yards to the EC26, 1ST DOWN BU (Dorian Stroud). |
| Bu | 1-10 | at Ec26 | N. Sheehan pass incomplete to N. James. |
| Bu | 2-10 | at Ec26 | N. Sheehan pass complete to J. Eaton for 9 yards to the EC17 (Dumont Schmidt). |
| Bu | 3-1 | at Ec17 | N. Sheehan rush for 3 yards to the EC14, 1ST DOWN BU (Kaleb Lingg). |
| Bu | 1-10 | at Ec14 | N. Sheehan pass complete to D. Brown for 14 yards to the EC0, 1ST DOWN BU, TOUCHDOWN, clock 11:39. |
| | | A. Sweeney kick attempt good. |
| | | Bluffton 7, Earlham 0 |
| | | Drive: 6 plays, 39 yards, TOP 02:01 |
| | | A. Sweeney kickoff 59 yards to the EC6, M. Williams return 7 yards to the EC13 (T. White). |
| Ec | 1-10 | at Ec13 | EARLHAM drive start at 11:34. |
| Ec | 1-10 | at Ec13 | Malik Reid rush for no gain to the EC13 (J. Runda;B. Schamp). |
| Ec | 2-10 | at Ec13 | Matt Couch rush for loss of 3 yards to the EC10 (R. Aelker). |
| Ec | 3-13 | at Ec10 | Matt Couch sacked for loss of 7 yards to the EC3 (P. Shroyer). |
| Ec | 4-20 | at Ec03 | Kaleb Lingg punt 37 yards to the EC40, S. Frost return 1 yards to the EC39, out-of-bounds (Justin Darden), PENALTY BU clipping (M. Shroyer) 10 yards to the EC49, 1st and 10, BU ball on EC49. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, minus 10 yards, TOP 01:49 |
| Bu | 1-10 | at Ec49 | BLUFFTON drive start at 09:45. |
| Bu | 1-10 | at Ec49 | C. Alexander rush for 2 yards to the EC47, out-of-bounds (Dumont Schmidt). |
| Bu | 2-8 | at Ec47 | C. Alexander rush for 5 yards to the EC42 (Junior Jean). |
| Bu | 3-3 | at Ec42 | C. Alexander rush for 7 yards to the EC35, 1ST DOWN BU (Kaleb Lingg;Dumont Schmidt). |
| Bu | 1-10 | at Ec35 | N. Sheehan pass incomplete to D. Brown. |
| Bu | 2-10 | at Ec35 | C. Alexander rush for 3 yards to the EC32 (Dumont Schmidt;Kollin Wheat). |
| Bu | 3-7 | at Ec32 | N. Sheehan pass complete to S. Frost for 8 yards to the EC24, 1ST DOWN BU (Dumont Schmidt). |
| Bu | 1-10 | at Ec24 | C.J. Sewell rush for 2 yards to the EC22 (Tyler Teresa). |
| Bu | 2-8 | at Ec22 | C.J. Sewell rush for loss of 3 yards to the EC25 (Kaleb Lingg). |
| Bu | 3-11 | at Ec25 | N. Sheehan pass complete to D. Brown for 25 yards to the EC0, 1ST DOWN BU, TOUCHDOWN, clock 06:04. |
| | | A. Sweeney kick attempt good. |
| | | Bluffton 14, Earlham 0 |
| | | Drive: 9 plays, 49 yards, TOP 03:51 |
| | | A. Sweeney kickoff 49 yards to the EC16, Kenny Williams return 11 yards to the EC27 (P. Shroyer;M. Shroyer). |
| Ec | 1-10 | at Ec27 | EARLHAM drive start at 05:54. |
| Ec | 1-10 | at Ec27 | Matt Couch pass incomplete to Leslie Dunlap. |
| Ec | 2-10 | at Ec27 | Tre Stephens rush for 4 yards to the EC31 (R. Aelker). |
| Ec | 3-6 | at Ec31 | Matt Couch pass complete to M. Williams for 7 yards to the EC38, 1ST DOWN EC, out-of-bounds (C. Miller). |
| Ec | 1-10 | at Ec38 | PENALTY EC false start (Kenny Williams) 5 yards to the EC33. |
| Ec | 1-15 | at Ec33 | Matt Couch pass incomplete to Jalen Kenner. |
| Ec | 2-15 | at Ec33 | Tre Stephens rush for no gain to the EC33 (W. Herman). |
| Ec | 3-15 | at Ec33 | Matt Couch pass complete to M. Williams for 12 yards to the EC45, out-of-bounds (C. Miller). |
| Ec | 4-3 | at Ec45 | Kaleb Lingg punt 24 yards to the BU31, R. Aelker return 0 yards to the BU31, fumble by R. Aelker recovered by EC TEAM at BU31. |
| | | Drive: 6 plays, 18 yards, TOP 01:52 |
| Ec | 1-10 | at Bu31 | EARLHAM drive start at 04:02. |
| Ec | 1-10 | at Bu31 | Malik Reid rush for loss of 2 yards to the BU33 (W. Herman;B. Schamp). |
| Ec | 2-12 | at Bu33 | Matt Couch pass complete to Leslie Dunlap for 8 yards to the BU25 (B. Schamp). |
| Ec | 3-4 | at Bu25 | Matt Couch pass complete to M. Williams for 5 yards to the BU20, 1ST DOWN EC (J. Hadley). |
| Ec | 1-10 | at Bu20 | Matt Couch pass incomplete to Jalen Kenner (C. Miller). |
| Ec | 2-10 | at Bu20 | Malik Reid rush for 4 yards to the BU16 (M. Holden). |
| Ec | 3-6 | at Bu16 | Matt Couch pass complete to Kenny Williams for 1 yard to the BU15 (M. Holden;D. Whidbee). |
| Ec | 4-5 | at Bu15 | Matt Couch pass incomplete to M. Williams. |
| | | Drive: 7 plays, 16 yards, TOP 02:35 |
| Bu | 1-10 | at Bu15 | BLUFFTON drive start at 01:27. |
| Bu | 1-10 | at Bu15 | PENALTY BU false start (M. Brown) 5 yards to the BU10. |
| Bu | 1-15 | at Bu10 | E. Fox rush for 8 yards to the BU18 (Wayne Wells;Ben Ballinger). |
| Bu | 2-7 | at Bu18 | C.J. Sewell rush for 2 yards to the BU20 (Kollin Wheat). |
| Bu | 3-5 | at Bu20 | N. Sheehan pass incomplete to D. Brown, dropped pass. |
| Bu | 4-5 | at Bu20 | B. McBride punt 40 yards to the EC40, Kaleb Lingg return 7 yards to the EC47 (B. Swavel;M. Holden). |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 5 yards, TOP 01:27 |
| Ec | 1-10 | at Ec47 | EARLHAM drive start at 00:00. |
| | | Bluffton 14, Earlham 0 |
| Ec | 1-10 | at Ec47 | Start of 2nd quarter, clock 15:00. |
| Ec | 1-10 | at Ec47 | Alonzo Genelin pass complete to Leslie Dunlap for 11 yards to the BU42, 1ST DOWN EC (M. Shroyer). |
| Ec | 1-10 | at Bu42 | Alonzo Genelin pass complete to Kenny Williams for 4 yards to the BU38 (P. Shroyer). |
| Ec | 2-6 | at Bu38 | Tre Stephens rush for 12 yards to the BU26, 1ST DOWN EC (E. Bohlen;M. Shroyer). |
| Ec | 1-10 | at Bu26 | PENALTY EC false start 5 yards to the BU31. |
| Ec | 1-15 | at Bu31 | Alonzo Genelin pass complete to Jalen Kenner for 12 yards to the BU19 (B. Swavel). |
| Ec | 2-3 | at Bu19 | PENALTY EC false start (Leslie Dunlap) 5 yards to the BU24. |
| Ec | 2-8 | at Bu24 | Alonzo Genelin pass incomplete to M. Williams. |
| Ec | 3-8 | at Bu24 | Alonzo Genelin pass complete to Jalen Kenner for 11 yards to the BU13, 1ST DOWN EC (J. Michaels;J. Hadley). |
| Ec | 1-10 | at Bu13 | Alonzo Genelin rush for 3 yards to the BU10 (R. Leopold). |
| Ec | 2-7 | at Bu10 | Tre Stephens rush for no gain to the BU10 (J. Hadley). |
| Ec | 3-7 | at Bu10 | Alonzo Genelin rush for 6 yards to the BU4 (J. Runda;J. Michaels). |
| Ec | 4-1 | at Bu04 | Tre Stephens rush for 3 yards to the BU1, 1ST DOWN EC (W. Herman;J. Runda). |
| Ec | 1-G | at Bu01 | Malik Reid rush for 1 yard to the BU0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 11:00. |
| | | John Hood kick attempt failed (blocked) (blocked by R. Leopold). |
| | | Bluffton 14, Earlham 6 |
| Ec | 1-G | at Ec35 | PENALTY BU face mask 15 yards to the 50 yardline. |
| | | Drive: 11 plays, 53 yards, TOP 04:00 |
| | | John Hood kickoff 47 yards to the BU3, C. Alexander return 20 yards to the BU23, fumble forced by Kaleb Lingg, fumble by C. Alexander recovered by EC Justin Darden at BU28. |
| Ec | 1-10 | at Bu28 | EARLHAM drive start at 10:53. |
| Ec | 1-10 | at Bu28 | Lance Sherwood pass incomplete to Leslie Dunlap. |
| Ec | 2-10 | at Bu28 | Alonzo Genelin pass incomplete to M. Williams. |
| Ec | 3-10 | at Bu28 | Alonzo Genelin pass complete to Leslie Dunlap for 10 yards to the BU18, 1ST DOWN EC, out-of-bounds (M. Shroyer;W. Herman). |
| Ec | 1-10 | at Bu18 | Alonzo Genelin pass incomplete to Leslie Dunlap. |
| Ec | 2-10 | at Bu18 | Tre Stephens rush for 3 yards to the BU15 (J. Runda). |
| Ec | 3-7 | at Bu15 | Alonzo Genelin pass incomplete to Leslie Dunlap (M. Shroyer). |
| Ec | 4-7 | at Bu15 | Alonzo Genelin pass incomplete to Jalen Kenner, dropped pass. |
| | | Drive: 7 plays, 13 yards, TOP 01:03 |
| Bu | 1-10 | at Bu15 | BLUFFTON drive start at 09:50. |
| Bu | 1-10 | at Bu15 | N. Sheehan pass complete to S. Frost for 4 yards to the BU19, out-of-bounds (Justin Darden). |
| Bu | 2-6 | at Bu19 | N. Sheehan pass complete to C.J. Sewell for 6 yards to the BU25, 1ST DOWN BU (Denis Caulley). |
| Bu | 1-10 | at Bu25 | C.J. Sewell rush for 5 yards to the BU30 (Tyler Teresa;Nate McCormack). |
| Bu | 2-5 | at Bu30 | N. Sheehan pass complete to C.J. Sewell for 7 yards to the BU37, 1ST DOWN BU (Kaleb Lingg). |
| Bu | 1-10 | at Bu37 | PENALTY BU false start 5 yards to the BU32. |
| Bu | 1-15 | at Bu32 | N. Sheehan pass incomplete to N. James, QB hurry by Nate McCormack. |
| Bu | 2-15 | at Bu32 | N. Sheehan pass incomplete to N. James (Dumont Schmidt). |
| Bu | 3-15 | at Bu32 | N. Sheehan pass incomplete to D. Brown (Junior Jean). |
| Bu | 4-15 | at Bu32 | B. McBride punt 31 yards to the EC37, fair catch by Kaleb Lingg. |
| | | Drive: 7 plays, 17 yards, TOP 01:39 |
| Ec | 1-10 | at Ec37 | EARLHAM drive start at 08:11. |
| Ec | 1-10 | at Ec37 | Malik Reid rush for 7 yards to the EC44 (M. Shroyer;E. Bohlen). |
| Ec | 2-3 | at Ec44 | Matt Couch pass incomplete to Leslie Dunlap. |
| Ec | 3-3 | at Ec44 | Matt Couch pass complete to M. Williams for 7 yards to the BU49, 1ST DOWN EC (J. Parker). |
| Ec | 1-10 | at Bu49 | Matt Couch rush for 7 yards to the BU42, PENALTY BU personal foul (E. Bohlen) 15 yards to the BU27, 1ST DOWN EC. |
| Ec | 1-10 | at Bu27 | 1st and 10. |
| Ec | 1-10 | at Bu27 | Malik Reid rush for 2 yards to the BU25 (P. Shroyer). |
| Ec | 2-8 | at Bu25 | PENALTY EC false start (Matt Couch) 5 yards to the BU30. |
| Ec | 2-13 | at Bu30 | Matt Couch pass intercepted by T. Lind at the BU12, T. Lind return 3 yards to the BU15 (Ryan Hayes) (T. Reaves). |
| | | Drive: 6 plays, 33 yards, TOP 02:08 |
| Bu | 1-10 | at Bu15 | BLUFFTON drive start at 06:03. |
| Bu | 1-10 | at Bu15 | C. Alexander rush for 8 yards to the BU23 (Kaleb Lingg). |
| Bu | 2-2 | at Bu23 | N. Sheehan pass incomplete, QB hurry by Lajay Kelly. |
| Bu | 3-2 | at Bu23 | N. Sheehan pass incomplete to D. Harrington, PENALTY EC pass interference (Dumont Schmidt) 5 yards to the BU28, 1ST DOWN BU, NO PLAY. |
| Bu | 1-10 | at Bu28 | N. Sheehan pass incomplete to D. Harrington (Denis Caulley). |
| Bu | 2-10 | at Bu28 | C. Alexander rush for 12 yards to the BU40, 1ST DOWN BU, out-of-bounds (Dumont Schmidt). |
| Bu | 1-10 | at Bu40 | C. Alexander rush for 6 yards to the BU46 (Nate McCormack). |
| Bu | 2-4 | at Bu46 | D Thomas-Wright rush for 5 yards to the EC49, out-of-bounds (Denis Caulley;Justin Darden), PENALTY BU holding (D. Harrington) 10 yards to the BU41. |
| Bu | 2-9 | at Bu41 | 2nd and 9. |
| Bu | 2-9 | at Bu41 | N. Sheehan rush for 6 yards to the BU47 (Tyler Teresa). |
| Bu | 3-3 | at Bu47 | C. Alexander rush for 8 yards to the EC45, 1ST DOWN BU (Dalton Chingman). |
| Bu | 1-10 | at Ec45 | N. Sheehan sacked for loss of 7 yards to the BU48 (Lajay Kelly), fumble by N. Sheehan recovered by EC Allen Eugene at BU45. |
| | | Drive: 9 plays, 30 yards, TOP 03:05 |
| Ec | 1-10 | at Bu45 | EARLHAM drive start at 02:58. |
| Ec | 1-10 | at Bu45 | Matt Couch pass complete to Jalen Kenner for 20 yards to the BU25, 1ST DOWN EC (M. Holden). |
| Ec | 1-10 | at Bu25 | Matt Couch sacked for loss of 5 yards to the BU30 (H. Bosch). |
| Ec | 2-15 | at Bu30 | Matt Couch pass complete to Kenny Williams for 20 yards to the BU10, 1ST DOWN EC (D. Whidbee). |
| Ec | 1-G | at Bu10 | Matt Couch rush for loss of 1 yard to the BU11 (W. Herman;J. Michaels). |
| Ec | 2-G | at Bu11 | Matt Couch rush for 6 yards to the BU5 (J. Michaels;J. Runda). |
| Ec | 3-G | at Bu05 | Matt Couch pass incomplete to Leslie Dunlap. |
| Ec | 4-G | at Bu05 | John Hood field goal attempt from 22 GOOD, clock 01:06. |
| | | Bluffton 14, Earlham 9 |
| | | Drive: 7 plays, 40 yards, TOP 01:52 |
| | | John Hood kickoff 42 yards to the BU23, M. Ellis return 0 yards to the BU23. |
| Bu | 1-10 | at Bu23 | BLUFFTON drive start at 01:06. |
| Bu | 1-10 | at Bu23 | N. Sheehan pass complete to S. Frost for 23 yards to the BU46, 1ST DOWN BU (Dalton Chingman). |
| Bu | 1-10 | at Bu46 | N. Sheehan pass complete to S. Frost for 17 yards to the EC37, 1ST DOWN BU (Tyler Teresa). |
| Bu | 1-10 | at Ec37 | N. Sheehan pass complete to C.J. Sewell for 12 yards to the EC25, 1ST DOWN BU (Dumont Schmidt). |
| Bu | 1-10 | at Ec25 | PENALTY BU illegal formation 5 yards to the EC30. |
| Bu | 1-15 | at Ec30 | N. Sheehan pass complete to C.J. Sewell for 7 yards to the EC23 (Tyler Teresa), PENALTY EC personal foul 12 yards to the EC11, 1ST DOWN BU. |
| Bu | 1-10 | at Ec11 | 1st and 10. |
| Bu | 1-10 | at Ec11 | Timeout Bluffton, clock 00:16. |
| Bu | 1-10 | at Ec11 | N. Sheehan pass incomplete to N. James. |
| Bu | 2-10 | at Ec11 | N. Sheehan pass incomplete to N. James (Dumont Schmidt). |
| Bu | 3-10 | at Ec11 | N. Sheehan pass incomplete to S. Frost, QB hurry by Lajay Kelly. |
| Bu | 4-10 | at Ec11 | Timeout Earlham, clock 00:02. |
| Bu | 4-10 | at Ec11 | A. Sweeney field goal attempt from 29 BLOCKED, recovered by EC Dumont Schmidt at EC2 spot at EC2, clock 00:00 (blocked by Justin Darden), Dumont Schmidt for 22 yards to the EC24 (E. Gonzalez). |
| | | Drive: 8 plays, 66 yards, TOP 01:06 |
| Ec | 1-10 | at Ec24 | End of half, clock 00:00. |
| | | Bluffton 14, Earlham 9 |
| Ec | 1-10 | at Ec24 | Start of 3rd quarter, clock 15:00, EC ball on EC35. |
| | | John Hood kickoff 49 yards to the BU16, C.J. Sewell return 18 yards to the BU34 (Junior Jean). |
| Bu | 1-10 | at Bu34 | BLUFFTON drive start at 14:56. |
| Bu | 1-10 | at Bu34 | N. Sheehan pass complete to D. Harrington for 6 yards to the BU40 (D. Curtis-Webs;Dumont Schmidt). |
| Bu | 2-4 | at Bu40 | C.J. Sewell rush for 6 yards to the BU46, 1ST DOWN BU (Dumont Schmidt). |
| Bu | 1-10 | at Bu46 | N. Sheehan rush for 14 yards to the EC40, 1ST DOWN BU (Dumont Schmidt;D. Curtis-Webs). |
| Bu | 1-10 | at Ec40 | N. Sheehan pass complete to D. Harrington for 2 yards to the EC38 (Dumont Schmidt), PENALTY BU illegal formation 5 yards to the EC45, NO PLAY. |
| Bu | 1-15 | at Ec45 | E. Fox rush for 6 yards to the EC39 (Junior Jean), PENALTY EC face mask (Junior Jean) 15 yards to the EC24, 1ST DOWN BU. |
| Bu | 1-10 | at Ec24 | 1st and 10. |
| Bu | 1-10 | at Ec24 | E. Fox rush for 4 yards to the EC20 (Dumont Schmidt;Denis Caulley). |
| Bu | 2-6 | at Ec20 | C. Alexander rush for 5 yards to the EC15, out-of-bounds (Justin Darden). |
| Bu | 3-1 | at Ec15 | D Thomas-Wright rush for 15 yards to the EC0, 1ST DOWN BU, TOUCHDOWN, clock 12:34. |
| | | A. Sweeney kick attempt good. |
| | | Bluffton 21, Earlham 9 |
| | | Drive: 7 plays, 66 yards, TOP 02:26 |
| | | A. Sweeney kickoff 45 yards to the EC20, Kenny Williams return 7 yards to the EC27 (T. White). |
| Ec | 1-10 | at Ec27 | EARLHAM drive start at 12:30. |
| Ec | 1-10 | at Ec27 | Malik Reid rush for 1 yard to the EC28 (B. Schamp). |
| Ec | 2-9 | at Ec28 | Matt Couch sacked for loss of 8 yards to the EC20 (R. Aelker). |
| Ec | 3-17 | at Ec20 | Matt Couch rush for 3 yards to the EC23 (J. Runda). |
| Ec | 4-14 | at Ec23 | Kaleb Lingg punt 42 yards to the BU35, S. Frost return 9 yards to the BU44 (Justin Darden). |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, minus 4 yards, TOP 01:51 |
| Bu | 1-10 | at Bu44 | BLUFFTON drive start at 10:39. |
| Bu | 1-10 | at Bu44 | C.J. Sewell rush for 7 yards to the EC49 (D. Curtis-Webs). |
| Bu | 2-3 | at Ec49 | C.J. Sewell rush for 1 yard to the EC48, out-of-bounds (Justin Darden), PENALTY BU holding 10 yards to the BU42. |
| Bu | 2-12 | at Bu42 | 2nd and 12. |
| Bu | 2-12 | at Bu42 | N. Sheehan pass complete to C.J. Sewell for 3 yards to the BU45 (Kollin Wheat). |
| Bu | 3-9 | at Bu45 | TEAM rush for loss of 20 yards to the BU25, fumble forced by Lajay Kelly, fumble by TEAM recovered by BU TEAM at BU25. |
| Bu | 4-29 | at Bu25 | B. McBride punt 25 yards to the 50 yardline, fair catch by Kaleb Lingg. |
| | | Drive: 4 plays, minus 19 yards, TOP 01:50 |
| Ec | 1-10 | at Ec50 | EARLHAM drive start at 08:49. |
| Ec | 1-10 | at Ec50 | Matt Couch pass complete to Jalen Kenner for 22 yards to the BU28, 1ST DOWN EC (M. Shroyer). |
| Ec | 1-10 | at Bu28 | Matt Couch pass incomplete to Lance Sherwood (P. Shroyer). |
| Ec | 2-10 | at Bu28 | Malik Reid rush for no gain to the BU28 (R. Leopold). |
| Ec | 3-10 | at Bu28 | Matt Couch pass complete to Jalen Kenner for 9 yards to the BU19 (P. Shroyer). |
| Ec | 4-1 | at Bu19 | PENALTY EC false start (Tyler Lawrence) 5 yards to the BU24. |
| Ec | 4-6 | at Bu24 | Matt Couch pass complete to M. Williams for 10 yards to the BU14 (J. Runda), PENALTY EC holding 10 yards to the BU34, NO PLAY. |
| Ec | 4-16 | at Bu34 | Kaleb Lingg punt 34 yards to the BU0, touchback. |
| | | Drive: 4 plays, 16 yards, TOP 01:58 |
| Bu | 1-10 | at Bu20 | BLUFFTON drive start at 06:51. |
| Bu | 1-10 | at Bu20 | N. Sheehan pass complete to E. Fox for 1 yard to the BU21, out-of-bounds. |
| Bu | 2-9 | at Bu21 | E. Fox rush for loss of 1 yard to the BU20 (Buddy O'Dell;Kollin Wheat). |
| Bu | 3-10 | at Bu20 | N. Sheehan pass incomplete to S. Frost, dropped pass, PENALTY BU holding declined. |
| Bu | 4-10 | at Bu20 | B. McBride punt 27 yards to the BU47, fair catch by Kaleb Lingg. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 0 yards, TOP 00:58 |
| Ec | 1-10 | at Bu47 | EARLHAM drive start at 05:53. |
| Ec | 1-10 | at Bu47 | Matt Couch pass complete to M. Williams for 7 yards to the BU40, out-of-bounds (B. Swavel). |
| Ec | 2-3 | at Bu40 | Matt Couch pass incomplete to M. Williams. |
| Ec | 3-3 | at Bu40 | Tre Stephens rush for 4 yards to the BU36, 1ST DOWN EC (J. Runda;T. Lind). |
| Ec | 1-10 | at Bu36 | Matt Couch pass incomplete to James Johnson. |
| Ec | 2-10 | at Bu36 | Tre Stephens rush for 2 yards to the BU34 (R. Aelker;B. Schamp). |
| Ec | 3-8 | at Bu34 | Matt Couch sacked for loss of 5 yards to the BU39 (R. Aelker). |
| Ec | 4-13 | at Bu39 | Kaleb Lingg punt 36 yards to the BU3, downed. |
| | | Drive: 6 plays, 8 yards, TOP 02:30 |
| Bu | 1-10 | at Bu03 | BLUFFTON drive start at 03:23. |
| Bu | 1-10 | at Bu03 | N. Sheehan pass incomplete to D. Brown, PENALTY EC offside defense 5 yards to the BU8, NO PLAY. |
| Bu | 1-5 | at Bu08 | C. Alexander rush for 2 yards to the BU10 (Kollin Wheat). |
| Bu | 2-3 | at Bu10 | N. Sheehan pass complete to S. Frost for 4 yards to the BU14, 1ST DOWN BU (D. Curtis-Webs;Justin Darden). |
| Bu | 1-10 | at Bu14 | C.J. Sewell rush for 2 yards to the BU16 (Tyler Teresa). |
| Bu | 2-8 | at Bu16 | PENALTY BU false start (B. Kress) 5 yards to the BU11. |
| Bu | 2-13 | at Bu11 | N. Sheehan pass incomplete to D Thomas-Wright, QB hurry by Nate McCormack. |
| Bu | 3-13 | at Bu11 | N. Sheehan pass incomplete to N. James, QB hurry by Kollin Wheat. |
| Bu | 4-13 | at Bu11 | B. McBride punt 47 yards to the EC42, downed. |
| | | Drive: 5 plays, 8 yards, TOP 02:12 |
| Ec | 1-10 | at Ec42 | EARLHAM drive start at 01:11. |
| Ec | 1-10 | at Ec42 | Matt Couch pass complete to Malik Reid for 2 yards to the EC44 (J. Hadley). |
| Ec | 2-8 | at Ec44 | Matt Couch pass complete to Lance Sherwood for 14 yards to the BU42, 1ST DOWN EC (R. DeBone). |
| Ec | 1-10 | at Bu42 | Matt Couch pass incomplete. |
| Ec | 2-10 | at Bu42 | Matt Couch pass incomplete to Kenny Williams. |
| Ec | 3-10 | at Bu42 | Matt Couch rush for 5 yards to the BU37 (J. Michaels;J. Parker). |
| | | Drive: 5 plays, 21 yards, TOP 01:20 |
| | | Bluffton 21, Earlham 9 |
| Ec | 4-5 | at Bu37 | Start of 4th quarter, clock 15:00. |
| Ec | 4-5 | at Bu37 | Kaleb Lingg punt 28 yards to the BU9, downed. |
| | | Drive: 5 plays, 21 yards, TOP 01:20 |
| Bu | 1-10 | at Bu09 | BLUFFTON drive start at 14:51. |
| Bu | 1-10 | at Bu09 | D Thomas-Wright rush for 11 yards to the BU20, 1ST DOWN BU (Kaleb Lingg;Jacob Keolanui). |
| Bu | 1-10 | at Bu20 | N. Sheehan pass complete to D. Brown for 7 yards to the BU27, out-of-bounds (Junior Jean). |
| Bu | 2-3 | at Bu27 | N. Sheehan pass incomplete to D. Brown, QB hurry by Kollin Wheat. |
| Bu | 3-3 | at Bu27 | N. Sheehan pass intercepted by Tyler Teresa at the BU31, Tyler Teresa return 0 yards to the BU31, QB hurry by Denis Caulley. |
| | | Drive: 4 plays, 18 yards, TOP 01:08 |
| Ec | 1-10 | at Bu31 | EARLHAM drive start at 13:43. |
| Ec | 1-10 | at Bu31 | Matt Couch pass complete to Jalen Kenner for 25 yards to the BU6, 1ST DOWN EC. |
| Ec | 1-G | at Bu06 | Tre Stephens rush for 2 yards to the BU4 (B. Schamp). |
| Ec | 2-G | at Bu04 | Matt Couch rush for 1 yard to the BU3 (T. Lind). |
| Ec | 3-G | at Bu03 | Tre Stephens rush for 3 yards to the BU0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 12:27. |
| | | John Hood kick attempt failed. |
| | | Bluffton 21, Earlham 15 |
| | | Drive: 4 plays, 31 yards, TOP 01:16 |
| | | John Hood kickoff 31 yards to the BU34, A. Siefker return 0 yards to the BU34. |
| Bu | 1-10 | at Bu34 | BLUFFTON drive start at 12:27. |
| Bu | 1-10 | at Bu34 | N. Sheehan pass complete to S. Frost for 5 yards to the BU39 (D. Curtis-Webs). |
| Bu | 2-5 | at Bu39 | C. Alexander rush for loss of 1 yard to the BU38 (Nate McCormack). |
| Bu | 3-6 | at Bu38 | N. Sheehan pass complete to D. Brown for 10 yards to the BU48, 1ST DOWN BU (Junior Jean;Kaleb Lingg), PENALTY EC personal foul (Nate McCormack) 15 yards to the EC37, 1ST DOWN BU. |
| Bu | 1-10 | at Ec37 | 1st and 10. |
| Bu | 1-10 | at Ec37 | C.J. Sewell rush for 6 yards to the EC31 (D. Curtis-Webs). |
| Bu | 2-4 | at Ec31 | D Thomas-Wright rush for 13 yards to the EC18, 1ST DOWN BU (Kollin Wheat;Allen Eugene). |
| Bu | 1-10 | at Ec18 | N. Sheehan pass complete to D. Brown for no gain to the EC18 (Junior Jean). |
| Bu | 2-10 | at Ec18 | D Thomas-Wright rush for 3 yards to the EC15 (D. Curtis-Webs;Jacob Keolanui). |
| Bu | 3-7 | at Ec15 | N. Sheehan pass complete to D. Brown for 15 yards to the EC0, 1ST DOWN BU, TOUCHDOWN, clock 09:22. |
| Bu | 1-G | at Ec03 | Timeout Bluffton, clock 09:22. |
| | | N. Sheehan pass attempt to D. Brown good. |
| | | Bluffton 29, Earlham 15 |
| | | Drive: 8 plays, 66 yards, TOP 03:05 |
| | | A. Sweeney kickoff 40 yards to the EC25, Lance Sherwood return 0 yards to the EC25. |
| Ec | 1-10 | at Ec25 | EARLHAM drive start at 09:22. |
| Ec | 1-10 | at Ec25 | M. Williams rush for loss of 1 yard to the EC24 (J. Parker). |
| Ec | 2-11 | at Ec24 | Matt Couch pass incomplete to James Johnson (J. Michaels). |
| Ec | 3-11 | at Ec24 | Matt Couch sacked for loss of 6 yards to the EC18 (R. Leopold;J. Runda). |
| Ec | 4-17 | at Ec18 | Kaleb Lingg punt 31 yards to the EC49, out-of-bounds. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, minus 7 yards, TOP 01:27 |
| Bu | 1-10 | at Ec49 | BLUFFTON drive start at 07:55. |
| Bu | 1-10 | at Ec49 | C. Alexander rush for 4 yards to the EC45 (Kaleb Lingg). |
| Bu | 2-6 | at Ec45 | C. Alexander rush for 4 yards to the EC41 (Tyler Teresa). |
| Bu | 3-2 | at Ec41 | D Thomas-Wright rush for 3 yards to the EC38, 1ST DOWN BU (Ben Ballinger). |
| Bu | 1-10 | at Ec38 | C.J. Sewell rush for loss of 1 yard to the EC39 (Kaleb Lingg). |
| Bu | 2-11 | at Ec39 | N. Sheehan rush for 10 yards to the EC29 (Ben Ballinger). |
| Bu | 3-1 | at Ec29 | N. Sheehan pass incomplete to D. Brown (Junior Jean), PENALTY EC Encroachment 5 yards to the EC24, 1ST DOWN BU, NO PLAY. |
| Bu | 1-10 | at Ec24 | E. Fox rush for 7 yards to the EC17 (Kaleb Lingg;Justin Darden). |
| Bu | 2-3 | at Ec17 | E. Fox rush for 2 yards to the EC15, out-of-bounds (D. Curtis-Webs). |
| Bu | 3-1 | at Ec15 | E. Fox rush for no gain to the EC15 (Fred Davis). |
| Bu | 4-1 | at Ec15 | D Thomas-Wright rush for 1 yard to the EC14, 1ST DOWN BU (D. Curtis-Webs;Nathan Wallace). |
| Bu | 1-10 | at Ec14 | Timeout Earlham, clock 02:55. |
| Bu | 1-10 | at Ec14 | D Thomas-Wright rush for 2 yards to the EC12 (Tyler Teresa). |
| Bu | 2-8 | at Ec12 | Timeout Earlham, clock 02:47. |
| Bu | 2-8 | at Ec12 | D Thomas-Wright rush for loss of 2 yards to the EC14 (Lajay Kelly). |
| Bu | 3-10 | at Ec14 | Timeout Earlham, clock 02:40. |
| Bu | 3-10 | at Ec14 | N. Sheehan pass complete to S. Frost for 14 yards to the EC0, 1ST DOWN BU, TOUCHDOWN, clock 02:33. |
| | | A. Sweeney kick attempt good. |
| | | Bluffton 36, Earlham 15 |
| | | Drive: 12 plays, 49 yards, TOP 05:22 |
| | | A. Sweeney kickoff 38 yards to the EC27, fair catch by Lance Sherwood. |
| Ec | 1-10 | at Ec27 | EARLHAM drive start at 02:33. |
| Ec | 1-10 | at Ec27 | Matt Couch pass incomplete to Jalen Kenner. |
| Ec | 2-10 | at Ec27 | Matt Couch pass incomplete to Adam Jolly, dropped pass. |
| Ec | 3-10 | at Ec27 | Matt Couch rush for 11 yards to the EC38, 1ST DOWN EC (J. Runda). |
| Ec | 1-10 | at Ec38 | Matt Couch pass complete to Jalen Kenner for 22 yards to the BU40, 1ST DOWN EC, out-of-bounds (D. Kersker). |
| Ec | 1-10 | at Bu40 | Matt Couch pass complete to Adam Jolly for 6 yards to the BU34. |
| Ec | 2-4 | at Bu34 | Matt Couch pass complete to M. Williams for 8 yards to the BU26, 1ST DOWN EC (J. Runda;B. Swavel). |
| Ec | 1-10 | at Bu26 | Matt Couch pass complete to Leslie Dunlap for 11 yards to the BU15, 1ST DOWN EC, out-of-bounds (C. Miller). |
| Ec | 1-10 | at Bu15 | Matt Couch pass incomplete to Leslie Dunlap, QB hurry by J. Runda. |
| Ec | 2-10 | at Bu15 | Matt Couch rush for 8 yards to the BU7 (J. Runda). |
| Ec | 3-2 | at Bu07 | Matt Couch pass complete to Adam Jolly for 6 yards to the BU1, 1ST DOWN EC (D. Dalton). |
| Ec | 1-G | at Bu01 | Timeout Bluffton, clock 00:44. |
| Ec | 1-G | at Bu01 | Matt Couch rush for 1 yard to the BU0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 00:40. |
| | | John Hood kick attempt failed (blocked) (blocked by TEAM). |
| | | Bluffton 36, Earlham 21 |
| | | Drive: 11 plays, 73 yards, TOP 01:53 |
| | | John Hood kickoff 15 yards to the 50 yardline, on-side kick, recovered by BU on 50 yardline, PENALTY EC illegal touching 5 yards to the EC45, 1st and 10, BU ball on EC45. |
| Bu | 1-10 | at Ec45 | BLUFFTON drive start at 00:40. |
| Bu | 1-10 | at Ec45 | TEAM rush for loss of 1 yard to the EC46. |
| Bu | 2-11 | at Ec46 | End of game, clock 00:00. |
| | | Drive: 1 plays, minus 1 yards, TOP 00:40 |
| | | FINAL SCORE |
| | | Bluffton 36, Earlham 21 |